-

 

 

 




Optimization Online





 

Risk Analysis 101 --- Robust-Optimization: the elephant in the robust-satisficing room

Moshe Sniedovich (moshe***at***ms.unimelb.edu.au)

Abstract: In 2001, info-gap decision theory re-invented the then 40-year old model of local robustness, known universally as radius of stability (circa 1960). Since then, this model of local robustness has been promoted by info-gap scholars as a reliable tool for the management of a severe uncertainty that is characterized by a vast (e.g. unbounded) uncertainty space, a poor point estimate of the uncertainty parameter and a likelihood- free quantification of uncertainty. Inexplicably, this absurd proposition has managed to pass muster in the review processes of academic books and journals. Small wonder then that info-gap’s robustness model was subsequently proposed, in a peer-reviewed article, as a framework for dealing with Taleb’s Black Swans and even . . . Unknown Unknowns?! More recently, the promotion of info-gap decision theory from the pages of peer- reviewed journals, has been conducted under the more general banner of the great merit of the robust-satisficing approach in decision-making, to the effect that advocates of this theory are now engaged in re-inventing the field of Robust Optimization. The trouble in all this is that the misguided rhetoric on robust-satisficing coming out of the info-gap literature, specifically the misguided rhetoric on the advantage of satis- ficing over optimizing that ends obscuring the obvious connection of robust-satisficing to Robust Optimization, had not been recognized for what it is, in the review process of peer-reviewed journals, such as Risk Analysis. In view of this state-of affairs, my objective in this discussion is to make it abundantly clear that info-gap’s robust-satisficing approach is in fact a step backwards to the early days of Robust Optimization, a step that completely ignores the tremendous progress over the past forty years or so, in this highly active area of research.

Keywords: Robust optimization, decision theory, radius of stability, maximin, local and global robustness, robust-satisficing, info-gap decision theory.

Category 1: Robust Optimization

Citation: Working Paper SM-12-1, July 2012, Department of Mathematics and Statistics, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne VIC 3010, Australia

Download: [PDF]

Entry Submitted: 07/04/2012
Entry Accepted: 07/04/2012
Entry Last Modified: 09/24/2012

Modify/Update this entry


  Visitors Authors More about us Links
  Subscribe, Unsubscribe
Digest Archive
Search, Browse the Repository

 

Submit
Update
Policies
Coordinator's Board
Classification Scheme
Credits
Give us feedback
Optimization Journals, Sites, Societies
Mathematical Optimization Society